Plumbpedia™ 12 - Flush-Off - Gilbert Plumbing Video PodCast
Plumbpedia
Plumbpedia™ 12

Flush-Off
 

Lexie conducts a flush-off with the Kohler Wellworth, Toto Carosoe, Kohler Cimarron, Mansfield Alto, and Vortens Vienna to see which one has the best flushing capacity.


Gilbert Plumbing has learned from 40 years of experience installing tens of thousands of toilets that the toilet with the highest flush capacity results in the greatest customer satisfaction. The high flush capacity of the Vortens Vienna means that it can take more abuse and oversized material (items that are not to be put in a toilet in the first place) and not plug up.

All the toilets in the Flush-Off perform much better than any of the gravity Low-Flush toilets from the 1990's. After the turn of the century, the manufacturers have been leapfrogging each other as they find new advancements in toilet technology. Some people are willing to trade flushing performance for a specific type of look.

An analogy would be if you bought a laptop computer a year ago and are happy with how it looks and performs. Today a different manufacturer comes out with a laptop that is 3x faster and costs less then what you paid a year ago. Would you bring your year old laptop back to the store and demand they take it back and give you the new one?

When congress put the low-flush toilet requirement into effect on January 1, 1994, the toilet manufacturers were not ready with the technology to have the toilets perform correctly. This resulted in the problems that are detailed at the following link:
UA Study Shows Leaks In Conservation Theory Behind Low-Flow Toilets.

From the University of Arizona study:
"Several companies manufacture low-consumption toilets, and some makes and models performed better than others. Also, the survey of homeowners also revealed a range of performance and satisfaction. Henderson and Woodard's study reports that some of the problems with low-consumption toilets were traced to how manufacturers designed their products. The industry's standard was set at 1.6 gallons and companies were free to achieve it any way they chose. That standard, developed in 1990 by the American Society of Mechanical Engineers, was adopted in local, state and national construction codes.

Most manufacturers kept the 3.5 gallon tanks but adjusted the inner workings to achieve a smaller flush, either by using a proprietary early-close flush valve flapper, or a toilet dam. Intentional or inadvertent replacement of a proprietary flapper valve, or removal of the restriction dam can cause a marked increase in water use. A few manufacturers opted to use a pressurized flush technology that uses a sealed bladder and captures household water pressure. These toilets are also noisier and more expensive. Other manufacturers went with different unique designs."
Read more...

As explained in the above paragraph, pressurized flush technology is much noisier and much more expensive.

 
Effective January 1, 1994, the Energy Policy Act of 1992 (Public Law 102-486) requires that all new toilets produced for home use must operate on 1.6 gallons per flush or less. Toilets that operate on 3.5 gallons per flush will continue to be manufactured, but their use will be allowed for only certain commercial applications through January 1, 1997 (NAPHCC, 1992).

The Vortens Vienna L EL water closet (3113 bowl, 3464 tank) was able to to remove 800 grams of solid waste in a single flush during The Maximum Performance (MaP) Testing of Popular Toilet Models (9th Edition - March 2007).


Other Related Links:

Gallons Of Reasons To Go Low Flow

UA Study Shows Leaks In Conservation Theory Behind Low-Flow Toilets

How Toilets Work

Waste Products - Excerpt from The Book 'Government Creep'

Frivolous Rant About Low-Flow Toilets

The Down Low On Low Flow

Potty Politics: Doesn't The Federal Government Have Anything Better To Worry About - Politics Of Low-Flow Toilets And Showers


Enjoy the convenience of automatic updates of new episodes with iTunes.
 
Search the iTunes Store for "Plumbpedia". In the search results you will find "Plumbpedia™".
Click on 'Subscribe" and iTunes will automatically download the most recent episode. You can also click here to subscribe through iTunes.
 
Go to your iTunes podcast list and click "Get" on the previous episodes to download them.
 
Set preferences for how often you want iTunes to check for new episodes.
 
To view an episode, just double click on it.
 
Link to Apple iTunes Download and Install Page.